Find Me on Google+

What The Heck Is SEO? A Rebuttal!

December 21, 2012 by · 8 Comments
Filed under: SEO 

Okay, I’m supposed to be “off” for Xmas…but this just in!

If you know anything at all about online marketing, the website smashingmagazine.com would be a spot that you’re already aware of…least in my world it’s one of the leading places for all things on marketing in various channels.

 In a recent Opinion Piece, a writer by the name of Paul Boag wrote a piece entitled “The Inconvenient Truth about SEO” that he opened up with the following paragraph –

“Do you own a website? Do you want to be number one on Google? Whatever you do, don’t spend money on aggressive search engine optimization (SEO)…” 

As you can tell, I’m going to NOT be okay with this…

But before I could mount (supposed to be off, eh?) any kind of a response, others stepped in to Rebut the claims made by this obviously not-an-SEO-practitioner….and I’m talking in this case about Bill Slawski and Will Critchlow…both exceptionally well known and respected SEO types on a global basis! Their own Rebuttal piece, entitled “What the Heck is SEO: A Rebuttal” can be found here and while they did the creation of same, they also used some of the globe’s best known SEO practitioners for extra wider-opinioned answers too!

They worked in conjunction with the Editors of SmashingMagazine too…and here’s how the Rebuttal piece was announced by same –

This article is a collective reply of the active members of the SEO community to the article “The Inconvenient Truth About SEO” in which Paul Boag discusses the value of search engine optimization for website owners. Written and edited by Bill Slawski and Will Critchlow, this article explains what exactly “SEO” means today and discusses the common view many Web designers share about the work of SEO companies.—Ed…”

As you can see, it’s going to be a real hootenanny, eh! Well for me at least, it truly was….here’s my own take on the Rebuttal piece…

I too, just like Bill/Will was intrigued by the title, clicked the link and oh my god…the author of same begins with commenting on “keyword densitys” and “gateway pages!!!”  Talk about being out of the loop for years and years…this was a bad sign…as I felt right off the bat that this writer knows NOTHING about SEO!

And as I noted, the response was the same for most of us real SEO practitioners…sigh…not a surprise at all!

 In fact, Bill/Will went on to actually show what an SEO practitioner does do – not what we’ve not done for years…and that to me spelt out the simple fact that as I see things TOO TOO many SMB owners are not getting the SEO that they think they’re paying for….as many of the comments around the web as well as on the articles mentionned here show.

You must click on the links above. You must read same and learn about what some folks STILL THINK SEO is…and what it really is….and the difference tween the two.

Oh – those experts who Bill/Will asked for comments are here – each one of same deserves a further click and to add their own blogs to your daily reading or RSS feeds…these folks KNOW SEO, eh!

Contributors to this post include…

Be Sociable, Share!
Google

Comments

8 Responses to “What The Heck Is SEO? A Rebuttal!”
  1. DennisG says:

    Thanks for sharing your perspective on this!
    One thing puzzles me. If you think the contributors deserve a click, as they know their stuff, why did you no-follow the links to their sites?
    They should deserve your link as well, right?

    DG

  2. Jim Rudnick says:

    @DennisG – ah….you noticed! Cool!

    Hoping some might…but what I did was to simply ‘cut&paste’ the same list from the Bill/Will Rebuttal piece in it’s entirety….

    And as they decided to NOFOLLOW originally, so did I….honestly, these folks do not need the linkJuice whatsoever….

    Good to see tho that someone did notice!

    :-)

  3. Gabrielle F says:

    SEO now may not be SEO tomorrow and yet some people won’t still accept the fact that the old tactics won’t work anymore. There will always be people who would talk as if they were experts of SEO but in reality they know nothing about it. Well, it’s one marketing trick right?

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. Zoomit.ca says:

    What The Heck Is SEO? A Rebuttal! | CanuckSEO…

    Okay, I’m supposed to be “off” for Xmas…but this just in! If you know anything at all about online marketing, the website smashingmagazine.com would be a spot that you’re already aware of…least in my world it’s one of the leading places for all things …

  2. BizSugar.com says:

    What The Heck Is SEO? A Rebuttal!…

    Okay, I’m supposed to be “off” for Xmas…but this just in! If you know anything at all about online marketing, the website smashingmagazine.com would be a spot that you’re already aware of…least in my world it’s one of the leading places for all things …

  3. [...] What The Heck Is SEO? A Rebuttal! | CanuckSEOBy Jim RudnickThe blog of veteran Hamilton based SEO search engine optimization specialist Jim Rudnick, a specialist with Local and National SEO search programs…CanuckSEO [...]

  4. Jason says:

    MERRY CHRISTMAS!…

    Have you tried .gov links for better ranking?…